In the realm of ministry, we often find ourselves longing for tangible results. We invest our time, energy, and prayers, hoping to witness a transformative change in the lives of those we serve. However, as we examine the experiences of two renowned evangelists, John Wesley and James Caughey, we come to realize that it is not solely our faithfulness that determines the outcome. Rather, it is God’s perfect timing and sovereign work in the hearts of individuals. Let us delve into their journeys and glean valuable insights about focusing on faithful service rather than being solely fixated on results.

The Tale of Two Preachers

In the year 1845, the Methodists in Vermont dispatched evangelist James Caughey to Europe to minister for two years. Caughey’s first destination was Birmingham, England, where he witnessed a fruitful five-month ministry. Encouraged by this initial success, he proceeded to Nottingham, England, and was invited to preach in the renowned Wesley Chapel—a vast sanctuary capable of seating between two and three thousand people.

Caughey’s arrival in Nottingham marked a significant contrast to John Wesley’s encounter with the town 105 years prior. Wesley, the great Methodist evangelist, had expressed disappointment as he observed the congregation’s lackluster response to the gospel. However, a transformation had begun to unfold. On Caughey’s inaugural Sunday in Nottingham, God poured out His Spirit upon the chapel, leading 136 souls to accept Jesus as their Lord and Savior. Subsequently, daily meetings were held, witnessing a constant flow of people embracing faith in Christ.

The Key to Success

What distinguished Caughey’s ministry was the Methodists’ meticulous follow-up system for new converts. Every name and address were promptly recorded, ensuring no one slipped through the cracks. Assigning converts to meet with church leaders and attend classes created a supportive environment for their spiritual growth. This organizational structure facilitated accountability, nurturing the newfound faith of the individuals.

As a result of Caughey’s faithfulness and the systematic approach to discipleship, by June 13, 1846, a mere five weeks since his arrival, 1,412 people had come to trust in Christ. Over a thousand of these new converts bid Caughey a tearful farewell at his final service in Nottingham—a powerful testament to the impact of faithful ministry.

Lessons Learned

Reflecting on these contrasting experiences, we must acknowledge that the varying outcomes were not indicative of Wesley or Caughey’s faithfulness. Rather, they serve as a reminder that the timing of God’s work is beyond our comprehension. Both men faithfully preached the Word, yet the results were in accordance with God’s divine plan.

It is crucial to remember that our role as servants of God is to faithfully sow and water the seeds of His truth. We must remain committed to our calling, leaving the results in God’s hands. As the apostle Paul eloquently reminds us in 1 Corinthians 3:7, “So then neither is he that planteth any thing, neither he that watereth; but God that giveth the increase.”

The experiences of Wesley and Caughey offer valuable insights into the nature of ministry. We are called to faithfully serve, trusting in God’s perfect timing and transformative power. Our responsibility lies in diligently planting and watering seeds, while recognizing that it is God who brings about the growth. So, let us persevere in faithfulness, leaving the outcomes to the One who holds all things in His hands.